Barston Bridge Consultation

Guidance Notes
Options for Barston Bridge
Consultation
https://yourvoicesolihull.uk.engagementhq.com/barston-bridge/survey_tools/options-for-barston-bridge-2
1. Answer honestly — you are not required to support both options!
You are not obliged to identify benefits of closure if you do not believe they exist.
-
It is acceptable to state:
“I do not believe there are benefits to closing the bridge.” -
If you feel any suggested benefits are minor or outweighed by harm, say so clearly.
​
Avoid guessing or inventing advantages simply because the question asks for them.
​
2. Specific examples are more influential than general statements.
Where relevant, explain:
-
How often you use the bridge
-
Why you use it (work, school, healthcare, caring responsibilities, business, social connection)
-
What would change if it closed (extra distance, time, cost, safety concerns)
Example: “Closing the bridge would add approximately 25 minutes to my journey to work and require travel on narrower, less safe roads.”
​
3. Consider all types of impact
​
Think beyond convenience alone. Impacts may include:
Community and social impacts
-
Isolation of residents
-
Access to schools, GP surgeries, hospitals, shops
-
Effects on elderly residents, families, or those without cars
Economic impacts
-
Local businesses, farms and services
-
Tradespeople, deliveries, tourism
-
Increased travel costs
Safety and emergency access
-
Ambulance, fire and police response times
-
Alternative routes in poor weather or flooding
Environmental impacts
-
Longer journeys and increased emissions
-
Traffic displacement to other villages or rural lanes
-
Impacts on walking, cycling or equestrian use
​
4. Think beyond the parish
The bridge serves a wider purpose than individual journeys.
You may wish to comment on:
-
Connectivity between communities
-
Whether closure would simply move traffic problems elsewhere
-
Consistency with wider policies (rural sustainability, climate goals, active travel)
5. Use free-text boxes fully
Free-text answers are often the most important part of a consultation.
Tips:
-
Use complete sentences
-
Be clear and calm in tone
-
Repeat key points if they apply to more than one question (this helps reinforce important themes)
​
6. Be consistent
​
Try to ensure your answers do not contradict each other.
If you oppose closure:
-
Make sure this is clear throughout your responses
-
If you acknowledge a theoretical benefit of closure, explain why it does not outweigh the harm
-
​
7. Remember how consultation responses are used
Responses are often:
-
Counted and summarised
-
Quoted in reports
-
Used to justify decisions
​
What you write becomes part of the formal evidence base. Clear, reasoned responses carry more weight than short or ambiguous ones.
8. You can submit your own view
​
Each response counts. You do not need technical expertise to take part — lived experience matters.
Final reminder
This consultation is a referendum and the majority 51% counts.Thoughtful, well-explained responses help ensure the importance of the bridge is properly understood.
​
​
​
